In Monday’s bail hearing for embattled chief financial officer of Chinese telecommunications giant Huawei, her lawyer argued nothing less than the dignity of her home country will be on the line if she makes bail.
David Martin made his final pitch for Meng Wanzhou’s release in a series of points aimed at convincing B.C. Supreme Court Justice William Ehrcke it wouldn’t be in the millionaire executive’s self-interest to flee Canada.
“It does not overstate to say she would embarrass China itself,” he told the judge.
The hearing resumed in a packed Vancouver courtroom on Monday, the next step in a case that has spooked international financial markets and threatened to damage the delicate trade relationship between the United States and China.
Meng, 46, who is also the daughter of Huawei’s founder, was arrested in Vancouver on Dec. 1 on suspicion of fraud involving violations of U.S. sanctions on Iran. American prosecutors are fighting for her extradition.
‘Woman of character and dignity’
Canadian prosecutors argued against granting Meng bail during her first court appearance in B.C. Supreme Court on Friday.
But Martin called the evidence against her “far from overwhelming,” arguing that her flight would be “inconceivable.”
“She is a woman of character and dignity. That she is deeply respectful of the rule of law,” Martin told the judge.
“It would take somebody who is utterly tone deaf to not understand that the United States has a political legal posture of adversity against both China and its largest company.”
Prosecutors have asked the court to consider the fact that Meng hasn’t travelled to the U.S. since 2017 as proof that she knows she faces the possibility of arrest.
But Martin said there are many reasons someone might not go to the U.S.
“I like to go to New York or L.A. as much as anybody — but it’s not necessary for people to travel there.”
Electronic surveillance proposed
Meng entered the packed courtroom wearing a green prison sweatsuit, her husband sitting in the front row near the glass prison enclosure.
For much of the morning, Martin focused on the effectiveness of electronic monitoring, proposing that Meng would wear a body-tracking device and be followed by a private security team — and that she would pick up the tab.
Lions Gate Risk Management Group chief executive Scott Filer, a former RCMP staff sergeant, testified that Meng would carry tracking equipment and wear a body tracking device to indicate her whereabouts.
The security team proposed for Meng would include a former RCMP officer previously responsible for all emergency response teams in B.C.
Filer said it would be the first time a risk-management company became involved in monitoring bail, and that while he can’t guarantee they won’t lose track of Meng, they would be able to answer the demands of the court.
Stephen Tan, a founding partner of a GPS monitoring services company, testified that his company has monitored 520 people out on bail — with only one person fleeing successfully.
Tan said the ankle bracelet that Meng would be required to wear can be removed with a pair of scissors, but that an alert is triggered when the bracelet is tampered with. He said the company has handled other high-profile extradition cases that involved concerns around hacking of the electronic devices.
Arrest ‘extremely egregious’: Chinese official
Meng allegedly used an unofficial company called Skycom to access the Iranian market between 2009 and 2014 — dealings that would be in violation of U.S. sanctions.
It’s also alleged Meng and other Huawei executives found out about U.S. criminal investigations into the company’s practices and began to alter travel patterns to avoid American authorities during or around 2017.
Multiple fraud charges against her each carry a maximum sentence of 30 years in prison.
Meng was en route from Hong Kong to Mexico when she was arrested while changing planes at Vancouver International Airport.
Her ongoing detention has stoked trade tensions between the United States and China.
China’s leaders have lashed out against Meng’s arrest and called for her immediate release. One top government official called the detention “extremely egregious,” according to the official Xinhua News Agency.
Vice Foreign Minister Le Yucheng summoned Canadian Ambassador John McCallum on Saturday and American Ambassador Terry Branstad on Sunday. He demanded that the U.S. vacate the arrest warrant, and warned McCallum of “grave consequences” if Meng is not released.
Asked Monday what those steps might be, foreign ministry spokesperson Lu Kang said only that it “totally depends on the Canadian side itself.”
B.C. drops China leg of trade mission
The proceedings have already upset trade relations between Canada and China — on Sunday, the B.C. government said it would be “rescheduling” the China leg of its Asian forestry trade mission over the “international judicial process” relating to Meng’s arrest.
Meng’s links to Vancouver
In a bail application, Meng said she has longstanding ties to Vancouver dating back at least 15 years as well as two homes in the city.
Vancouver police are investigating an alleged break-in at one of those homes on Sunday morning.
Court documents reveal that Meng was once a permanent resident of Canada and show pictures of Canadian government-issued identification, including her social insurance number and B.C. ID. She relinquished her residency nearly a decade ago.
In a sworn affadavit, Meng said she is innocent and will contest allegations against her at trial in the United States, if she is surrendered there.
Huawei is one of the world’s biggest suppliers of network gear for phone and internet companies. Meng’s father, Ren Zhengfei, is the company’s founder and CEO.
(中央社記者胡玉立多倫多10日專電)華為財務長孟晚舟保釋聽證會今天在溫哥華進行第二回合庭訊,孟晚舟的律師一開庭即稱,他的委託人將負擔交保後的居家監控開銷。
辯方律師馬丁(David Martin)7日在首次保釋聽證庭中一再強調,孟晚舟與加拿大有實質關連,「她在這裡有家,不會逃跑」。今天的聽證會上,辯方請到兩家保全公司作證,詳細說明一旦孟晚舟獲得保釋,可以執行相關的居家監控措施。
馬丁並指出,孟晚舟的丈夫劉曉棕已承諾擔任保證人,還會用他名下在溫哥華的兩棟房屋外加100萬加幣現金做為擔保,合計擔保金共1500萬元加幣,且劉曉棕會在孟晚舟交保後,與她一起住在溫哥華西28街的家中。
辯方律師強調,孟晚舟是有品格、有尊嚴、重法治的女性,完全沒有犯罪紀錄,努力成為其祖國的社會領袖和榜樣,她沒有動機不遵守法院命令,棄保潛逃。
辯方律師表示:「如果只是為了不嚴格遵守法院交保規定,而將自己一生事業抛棄, 對孟晚舟來說,是不可思議的事。」
孟晚舟今天出庭時,穿著與7日相同的綠色上衣,精神狀態看來不錯。溫哥華法庭擠進大批記者和華人社區人士,另有部分華人在法庭外抗議,指責加拿大幫助美國逮捕孟晚舟,全是出於齷齪的政治動機。
至於加中關係,已因加方逮捕孟晚舟一案,陷入谷底。
除了卑詩省政府昨天宣布暫停該省亞洲林業貿易代表團訪問中國之外,加拿大環球郵報(The Globe and Mail)報導,加拿大外交部副部長許卡特(Ian Shugart)原訂本週前往北京訪問,現在也已經延期。
